Poignantly if not somewhat hypocritically, the ftm (female to male) Reddit references our earlier post about Dr. Crane as the source for information about his practice, and goes on to allege that his practice has been dropped from the Kaiser Permanente California health plan due to the amount of lawsuits against him: We were not able to confirm whether Dr. Crane is still a listed physician with Kaiser Permanente from that insurers site, but at least one additional source seems to confirm that he is not. Carter v. Crane, CGC-16-554254 was dismissed December 10, 2018. What does this mean? I believe a large portion of the lack of information regarding these proceedings are due to the humiliation and shame incurred in such situations, as well as the smaller number of FTMs who seek out these surgeries. pallet space calculator amalie arena seat numbers dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit. People who have experienced transgender genital surgery recognize the deficiencies in the field and have called on WPATH to upgrade and change its standards: https://wpathopenletter.wordpress.com/2018/04/04/genital-surgery-open-letter/. The plaintiff had already undergone a vaginectomy (surgery to remove all or part of the vagina) and a scrotoplasty (a plastic surgery designed to transform part of the female genital area into a scrotum). To suggest that the medical malpractice system is merely some kind of adjunct health insurance is, in a word, facetious. Does anyone know of an experienced, reliable and professional attorney from Austin Texas who can help my friend? He graduated from UNIVERSITY OF IOWA in 2002. Dr. Curtis Crane, MD is a Urology Specialist in Greenbrae, CA and has over 21 years of experience in the medical field. After researching a long time hes the only one I would have gotten the surgery with. For an added bonus, prospective patients may even be able to receive a free initial surgery consultation, right there at the conference! Its because of this type of ignorance. Its not clear when Dr. Santucci joined Dr. Cranes practice, but he does not appear to have been part of the earlier Brownstein-Crane incarnation: Not to worry, though: Dr. Safir remains busy in San Francisco. Im sorry you went through that. Your comment will have a better chance of publication if it makes a constructive contribution to the topic at hand. I do not want to be rude, but its just almost impossible for me to build a reasonable phallus from a piece of flesh. FTMs need to wake up and realize the only time the news media is interested in them is if the are pregnant men. Please, FTMs, take care of yourselves and look out for each other. I am angry.. Now? The outcome has been good. My fianc can't even fit her hand around it and has screaming orgasms now. Suffice it to say that I wish we had gone to someone else. Most surgeon websites are not very informative and most 3rd party websites on this topic are broken and fragmented at best. Kendra, Im really sorry that this happened to you and your husband. Thats what everyone should be focusing on. This guy in my opinion is a butcher. A person may wish to pursue this type of penis surgery for many reasons. The lawsuit against Dr. Crane arose because, while M alleged that he repeatedly told Dr. Crane and his staff that he did not need a vaginectomy and a scrotoplasty, those having already been performed by Dr. Meltzer in 2011, M stated that Dr. Crane over-rode his instructions and both cut into the area where Ms vagina had previously been, and damaged and dis-placed Ms scrotum (as discussed more fully below). wondering if youd be willing to chat with me further? Susans Place, a major resource page for transgender people to connect and share resources, has a thread on Dr. Crane which contains only praise and, again, no mention of the extensive legal history cited above. Do you think that, being young children after all, they expect that one day the Gender Fairy will pay a visit? Planned Parenthood also got a big interview. After all, the Gender Fairy could someday deliver a real-life nightmare. Update: Top San Francisco phalloplasty surgeon now with 8 malpractice suits, our initial post about Dr. Crane and his legal troubles, a recent (2017) survey conducted by Medscape, a large-scale study using data from the National Practitioner Data Bank, all surgical partners in Dr. Cranes practice, insurance section of Dr. Cranes practices website, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Clauberg, Whats Current: South Korean women hold two day #MeToo speakout, https://wpathopenletter.wordpress.com/2018/04/04/genital-surgery-open-letter/, https://twitter.com/4th_WaveNow/status/1037791291143118849, https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/comments/apkb4r/honest_review_of_dr_thomas_satterwhite_san/, Catching up with renowned phalloplasty surgeon, Dr. Curtis Crane | 4thWaveNow. Thats it for our legal update, but for those of us who are interested in Dr. Crane and his business model, there have been some additional developments. Clearly, many of the lawsuits state that. Does he bat 100? Dr Crane would tell-all to patients and often it was like a game of telephone. One allegation common to virtually all of the above cases is that Dr. Crane over-promised and under-delivered in terms of the likely success, appearance, and functionality of the constructed genitals. brave fight to use the little girls room, at least nine former patients of Dr. Curtis Crane, an international hub of transgender surgery, nobody is better at magical thinking than young children, Catching up with renowned phalloplasty surgeon, Dr. Curtis Crane, over 90% of all medical malpractice cases, the plaintiff cannot bring another lawsuit based on the same facts, According to the Crane Centers Facebook page, Federal government embraces affirmative care: 4thWaveNow founder discusses in first public appearance, TMI: Genderqueer 11-year-olds cant handle too much info about sterilizing treatmentsbut do get on with those treatments, Dutch puberty-blocker pioneer: Stop blindly adopting our research, A birthday campaign for JK Rowling: Balanced media coverage of gender identity issues, Benji/gnc_centric: On being kicked off Twitter and Medium, Update: Twitter remains obstinate in defamatory lockout after Better Business Bureau complaint, 4thWaveNow lockout: Twitter employee admits mistake to journalist, yet account remains disabled, Former phalloplasty patient of Dr. Curtis Crane speaks out, Parents, keep listening to your gutnot the gender therapist, American Gender Physicians Need to Think More Like Europeans PJ Media, Breast binders and the helpful strangers pushing them on your son, Response to Fleming on ETLE | Survey Anon's Gender Blog. Perhaps some of his current or former patients will enlighten us. / you can be trans and love your genitals IDIOCY. 9 known men had horrible circumstances but the amount of men with success exceeds those tenfold. A reality check shall we say. Well drop you an email. Part 1 is here. I understand that you had a good experience with Dr. Crane, so lucky for you. Suicide or transition: The only options for gender dysphoric kids? Having seen the photos of what Dr Curtis Crane has done to my friends arm, that arm will never recover, believe that Dr Curtis Crane should stop performing phalloplasty. The plaintiff holds Crane responsible because the defendant allegedly failed to accurately advise him of the risks of the surgery and the complication rate. This is dangerous. Tags: ALT phalloplasty, bottom surgery, Dr. Crane, female to male gender reassignment, FTM, phalloplasty, Transsexual Male, transsexual surgery 2 So things have been pretty uneventful since surgery. Although its difficult to find comprehensive statistics, a recent (2017) survey conducted by Medscape found that 55% of all practicing U.S. physicians have been sued at least once. (plastic surgeon); Heidi Wittenberg, M.D. Blog posts on the matter can be found here, here, and here. A metoidioplasty is a surgical procedure that uses clitoral tissue that has been enlarged through testosterone use to form a neophallus. Trial is set for February 19, 2019. I do hope things are going better for you now. But for Jacobs parents, and their many peers, perhaps it should be. In fairness to Dr. Crane, lets start with some general observations about medical malpractice. And given the malpractice insurance premiums hes undoubtedly required to pay, he better be making some money at all this. According to the Crane Centers Facebook page, Dr. Brownstein retired in 2013, after having performed thousands of FTM chest surgeries and passing this extensive knowledge along to Dr. Crane. FTMs are a statistically smaller amount of the population. PS Your the first person I know that didnt have major complications, again Im happy for you, thats really cool. I will do whatever it takes to make sure no one goes through what I went through ever again. Another trans old school friend of mine attempted suicide after going trans. HARLEY QUINN AND POISON IVY #1. Successful phalloplastry operations are few and far between and this is being kept from transitioners in order to keep the burgeoning industry in business. We ask, why are these actual injuries, suffered by actual transgender people, so much less important to the transgender community than such nebulous insults as mis-gendering, the inability to access a desired dressing room, or hurtful Tweets? I had surgery with Dr. Crane and it was one complication after another that ruined my life emotionally and financially. Dr Crane is a very skilled surgeon. Consider the case of Windell Boutee, the Georgia cosmetic surgeon who filmed herself in the operating theatre rapping while performing surgery, whose patients only stepped forward after one brave woman spoke out. Scott, I had a fully successful phalloplasty, in Canada, and know many many others who are in the same boat. Hi Rose, it looks Dr. Crane has hired a PR person, this latest video interviewed has 11 followere, but the kids wont investigate information. Blair Hansen filed a complaint on Nov. 20 in the San Francisco Superior Court against Curtis N. Crane, M.D. All surgeries and procedures are experimental until its proven to work. 2. Please stop Dr Curtis. The court file reveals Ms journey to manhood, which, in his own words, entailed many surgeries. Ms transition journey is detailed below and all of the information is taken directly from the court file: Alas, Ms gender journey was far from over. From interrogatory answers filed in the Raynor case, cited above, we do know something about Dr. Cranes professional liability and medical malpractice coverage in 2016, the date the malpractice alleged in that case was claimed to have occurred (see Motion for Relief from Waiver of Discovery Objections dated April 16, 2018, Declaration of Corban J. Porter and Exhibit D thereto): Private settlement agreements also typically include NDA (or non-disclosure agreement) provisions, in which the parties agree to keep all terms of the settlement confidential, and further agree to the payment of damages in the event of a breach. Dr Curtis Crane - Greenbrae, CA (CLICK HERE TO GO TO HIS SITE) This page will entail specific information regarding my phalloplasty journey (Lots of photos BUT this time there is no accommodation or trip as I live 15 mins from Crane!) In 2009, M received a metoidioplasty, an operation that uses tissue from the clitoris, which has typically been enlarged from testosterone use, to form a neo-penis. This operation was performed by the famous Dr. Miroslav Djordjevi of Serbia, which was in the process of becoming, In 2011, M underwent his first phalloplasty or surgical construction of a penis, with Dr. Toby Meltzer. Dr. Crane is one of only a few surgeons in the world who is trained as both a plastic surgeon and urologist and has also completed fellowships in reconstructive urology and transgender surgery. We are cutting up our bodies and rearranging them..shit will happen, shit might happen, and then again, shit might not happen. His prior practice, Brownstein & Crane Surgical Services, seems to be out of business. In and of itself, this is not surprising. As I understand the objections to our coverage, they seem, first, to stem from a misapprehension (perhaps willful) of the purpose of medical malpractice law. I am also concerned about the lack of information concerning this topic, but I would also suggest the fact that cosmetic surgery is not as regulated as it should be, and thus cosmetic surgeons should be subject to more scrutiny. Crane's got absolutely ridiculous wait times because he's one of the high profile surgeons for phalloplasty. Your request has been completed. thanks you for speaking the truth, you are exactly right that these young people claiming your comments are harmfull, are doing more harm temselves. Third in a series. Dr crane moved to a place where the . Thank you. We are involved in one of them. So, its important to understand: When dismissal with prejudice is entered as part of a settlement, it does not indicate that anyone has ruled on the merits of the case. F*ck our comments section on our terrible site for giving a damn about these natal females. Dr. Curtis Crane is a board-certified plastic surgeon who is one of the top experts in Metoidioplasty in the United States. Second, it seems that activists are concerned that covering practitioners such as Dr. Crane will lead to increased gate-keeping and perhaps lower availability of medical care. I have been doing YouTube videos I think I will go public with it all. Since this surgery, the plaintiff has had two more surgeries, with other doctors, to obtain a larger scrotum, but they have both been unsuccessful. Can a phalloplasty be reversed at all? One can only imagine what life will be like for these patients in the years ahead, as they try to cope with malformed, misshapen, and certainly non-functional genitals. strongly considering finding another surgon. So returning to the celebrity trans kids at the beginning of this article: What do you suppose young Jacob, and Jacobs transgender peers, are hearing about their likely futures? The issue is that the State of California only allows ONE year from the date of INITIAL incident to sue for medical malpractice. Yes. A similar situation can be found in cosmetic surgery as a whole: there is still much stigma felt by people who seek out non trans related cosmetic surgery. TSSurgery.com, a site providing information for transgender people about surgeons and others, that also contains reviews, has a large section on Dr. Crane, but again, no mention of his legal troubles. https://cranects.com . We dont publish comments which spread suicide contagion and/or misleading information about suicidality. https://twitter.com/NewgentTGA/status/1278068392470159360?s=20, There is an important point that is missing. The damage in same can last a lifetimeno different than with the HRT cocktail and can lead to such wonderful things as circulatory issues and renal problems. 6. The main overall complaint I've heard from people is that he tends to be very optimistic when he talks with patients especially about post-op issues - this has led to some folks not realizing that something was as serious an issue as it was. Not entirely, you can have the Phallos or Penis removed, but you have a vagiasectomy to get this procedure doneNo more Vagina..Its a horrible surgery and should be illegal or this Surgeon should have his medical license removed. One more thing. 4thWaveNow contributor Worriedmom has practiced civil litigation for many years in federal and state courts. I belong to those secret and private groups to avoid the s#it like this. He never and I mean, never alluded to anything. That was the comment above not from you. A ninth malpractice case, Hansen v. Crane (CGC-18-571442), brought in November of last year, was also dismissed on January 14, 2019. I would like to remain anonymous. Any internet searches for brownsteincrane.com result in a re-direct to Crane Center for Transgender Surgery, a practice operating in California and Texas. Dr. Curtis Crane, MD is a board-certified plastic surgeon in Austin, Texas who specializes in Phalloplasty. Its full of uncertainty, worry about the future and decision-making, concern about ones place in the world. Many of the males who tend to run media outlets, whether LGBT, trans, or traditional, just dont see an important story in young womens genitalia being butchered by an incompetent surgeon. I am skeptical of ppl saying they had a fantastic phalloplasty. If your comment makes accusations against someone, please substantiate your allegations with source links. Twice, thankfully unsuccessful both times. A phalloplasty is done in a hospital under general anesthesia by a plastic surgeon and/or a urologist . We are seeking for better care and hopefully, no one will ever have to go under the knife of Dr. Crane. Moreover, several of the plaintiffs also allege that Dr. Cranes response, when confronted with complications or distressing symptoms following surgery, was inadequate, unconcerned, and even unfeeling. Doctor Crane is back in business, looking for more victims. Phalloplasty is a type of surgery to repair or construct a penis. I was actually the one to email you when you posted. Which is ridiculous. It must be hard to hear that current medical technology cannot really deliver your dream. Radial Forearm Flap (RFF) Phalloplasty is the most common type of Phalloplasty. Im not sure. Set after the events of HEROES IN CRISIS and smack in the middle of "Year of the . Research has revealed some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. Crane. Perhaps some of his current or former patients will enlighten us. Even after 6 years I would love to die today I cannot recover from Cranes brutality and despise the transgender community activist for promoting and protecting this butcher. He charged me $254,000 for this surgery. I dont like some of the language in the comments. One might reasonably conclude, then, that all of these actions have been settled out of court. Trial is set for June 24, 2019. Fourth your claim that the article criticizes the fact that Dr. Cranes practice is financially rewarding for him is simply baseless. This surgery cures dysphoria and correct many mens bodies. The plaintiff alleges Crane "encouraged" phalloplasty instead. I begged God for the month to kill me but unfortunately I am still alive and urinate in a broad spray with no sexual organs. Sometime things happen, so he has 8 malpractice suits, but how many has he performed well? Imagine being harmed by someone, like so beyond the point of return, and yet the only person who can help you is the person who did you harm. Would you like to guest post on this site? Also, please keep in mind that even if one has a complication (and perhaps this is why he isnt honest about them) they could fix it after many surgeries so I am assuming that under some medical legal jargon that it doesnt have to be reported if it can be resolved. Dr. Curtis Crane Dr. Richard Santucci: Texas: $11,000: Metoidioplasty, no UL: Dr. Marci Bowers : California: $8000 - $9500: * Yes, suicide is terrible, but stop holding people hostage with this because all rational discussion after that stops.. The smiling faces on the Stepford Wife wannabees, hawking the clinic of this quack, remind me of those lovely faces, of the attendants, in the Home from Soylent Green. What does that even mean, pimping out the victims? Why isnt The Trans Advocate warning people against this butcher? Otherwise, very informative article. Part 1 is here. He is a psychopath and shouldnt have a medical license. God bless you and yours. It is helpful to have the case number (also called an index or docket number), although a search can also be performed using the persons name, so those are provided below. which composer listed below had to hide their homosexuality? No. I get gender dysphoria, but at some point we have to have an understanding that we were born woman, no two ways about it. Not sure if you got? 2. Since our last coverage of medical malpractice litigation against renowned phalloplasty surgeon Curtis Crane, M.D., weve received frequent inquiries about the current status of the lawsuits and his practice. Who would insure him now? Any care is better than no care? Its impossible to know. dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit. Then, in March 2018, Dr. Garcia and another surgeon again performed surgery on M, this time to re-place the existing penis (which was also displaced), and to re-orient Ms scrotum. Some commentators argue that keeping medical malpractice settlement amounts confidential hurts the public: Secret nondisclosure agreements also affect patient safety by allowing bad doctors and other dangerous medical providers to continue to harm patients because their incompetency is hidden from their present and future patients and employers. Its scary, its something that many of us will never be able to bounce back from. I agree and Im transgender and Ive had a phalloplasty with Dr. Crane, it should be illegal.That is coming from someone that has had one. That is mostly reserved for older folks like me, who have a lifetime of bad health decisions that are just now catching up to them. Swelling was massive the first few days but that starts to go down. The donor site is thin and supple allowing the flap to be easily tubed and shaped into a phallus, and the relatively hairless skin provides erogenous sensation and often allows urethral reconstruction in a single stage. How? Its harmful saying that this surgery is experimental and dangerous. I have yet to speak with one trans man that had a Phalloplasty that worked properly or didnt suffer from grave complication. As with the other actions listed above, this lawsuit also alleged malpractice in connection with genital surgery: Interestingly, the plaintiff in that case alleged that at the time he consulted Dr. Crane, Dr. Crane told him that none of his patients had ever had a serious complication from phalloplasty, that it was a safe procedure, and that only 5% of his patients have needed surgical repairs.. Most doctors are cis straight men who actively do not want anyone born female to have what they have. 1. The case does not appear to be set for trial. and Does 1-30 alleging medical negligence. This has been a fairly easy recovery. As a final note, other than coverage by 4thWaveNow, there appears to be nothing on the internet about Dr. Curtis Crane that is not completely laudatory and admiring of his surgical skills and acumen. For what amount of damages? So please dont tell me that going trans is the perfect antidote to suicide: I wont believe you. It was actually a huge stressor for many patients who booked with him there and then the team fell through (and so those on his books had to reschedule either for a later date when they got a new team on board or have to come to California. According to the Crane Centers Facebook page, Dr. Brownstein retired in 2013, after having performed thousands of FTM chest surgeries and passing this extensive knowledge along to Dr. Crane. So, yes. Second and since youve come from abroad perhaps this isnt really your area but the number of malpractice lawsuits that have been filed against Dr. Crane is phenomenal for one doctor in such a short time period. I think thats cool you like your phallo, but if u havent gotten one and you are saying this thats dangerious. As with the other actions listed above, this lawsuit also alleged malpractice in connection with genital surgery: Interestingly, the plaintiff in that case alleged that at the time he consulted Dr. Crane, Dr. Crane told him that none of his patients had ever had a serious complication from phalloplasty, that it was a safe procedure, and that only 5% of his patients have needed surgical repairs.. This brings to a total of eight the number of times that Dr. Crane has now been sued for medical malpractice in San Francisco Superior Court. Of all those doctors, today only Drs. It could be zero, it could be $10 million. . This guy obviously doesnt understand who this monster really is. Part 3 is here. Is it worthwhile information to know hes been sued 8 times? Unlike some other surgeries, however, there is a fairly high risk of complications associated . The suits variously allege medical malpractice, medical negligence, and/or failure to . The lack of concern from the trans-focused media is unbelievable. In other words, it does not appear that an independent arbiter has reviewed the facts of these cases and ruled on whether the care provided either complied, or did not comply, with established standards of care. This is not surprising, since over 90% of all medical malpractice cases never go to trial. Ive not heard of this doctor, or the allegations against him, but I have known for some time that results for transmen where phalloplasty is concerned, quite frankly were pretty rubbish, which is why most transmen dont get that surgery. The plaintiff alleges negligence in connection with three transformative urological surgical procedures, including a procedure similar to a metoidioplasty, replacement of testicular implants, and the placement of a new 3-piece inflatable implant. So many men experienced the complete opposite and have the body they seek to have. 4thWaveNow contributor Worriedmom has practiced civil litigation for many years in federal and state courts. Nothing is a sure thing. Dr. Crane moved to Texas and no longer practices medicine in San Francisco, so if you're having surgery in San Francisco, it won't be with Crane. Facial Feminization. Theres a handful of surgeons who have decided (for whatever reasons) to focus on us and we know that we are all guinea pigs as they do their best efforts to hone their craft in a field where theres no text books or formal education. This makes sense, because otherwise no defendant would ever pay money in settlement of a litigation if he or she knew that the plaintiff could simply re-file the same lawsuit another day. Its impossible to know. [1] Interestingly, on March 7, 2019, Cranes defense counsel in this case was ordered to pay a $1,800 sanction for misuse of the discovery process.. Isnt there a consumer watchdog organisation that should be exposing the low success rate of these operations? Third in a series. Thank you for researching these cases. In my experience, his representing lawyers are cruel and demeaning-with zero regard that they are speaking to those who have experienced a tremendous amount of trauma by their clients (Dr Crane) hand. San Francisco Superior Court case number CGC18571442, California falls behind on water storage as losses mount for businesses, residents, Lawsuit claims big sellers of sports bras, other athletic apparel violate Prop 65 by not warning of BPA, New California policy review aims to require more cities to build more 'affordable' housing, Adult film firm Strike 3 Holdings continues to mass-file copyright lawsuits, Cal/OSHAs Permanent COVID-19 Standard: What Employers Should Know About Californias Next Phase in COVID-19 Compliance on February 28, 2023, Class action accuses YouTube of misleading consumers about cancellation, auto renewal after free trial, Humboldt County faces class action from landowners over marijuana-related code enforcement using satellite pics. Or do they believe that, as Diane Ehrensaft claims, God got it wrong, and someday they will return to the womb and re-emerge as their correct gender? San Francisco phalloplasty surgeon, Curtis Crane, M.D., continues his odyssey through the San Francisco court system. Stage is a complex concept because it means different things to different people. A lot of us want certain surgeries but we hold back b/c the outcomes arent quite worth the risks for us, lawsuits or not. The reports triggered a wave of mass hysteria across the country. Apparently, the cartoon had a lights flashing sequence that doctors said, in theory, could make a tiny fraction of children, with certain nervous system syndromes, possibly react with seizures. This type of transitioning does and has not been around long enough to determine a level of care and because of that its the wild wild west. Shame on California Politicians! No special education required. What we do know is that none of these dismissals appear to have been the result of a jury or other type of fact-finding proceeding that evaluated Dr. Cranes conduct and made any findings about negligence or malpractice. Shepherd v. Crane, CGC-17-559294, dismissed October 3, 2018. If the doctor is incompetent and has botched these surgeries, thats one thing, but if not and these are down to other reasons, then what can you do? In and of itself, this is not surprising. Third I find your lack of compassion for these plaintiffs to be somewhat unsettling.

Most Potent Kratom Strains Chart, Will Grass Seed Grow If I Just Throw It Down, Articles D